Roth vs Traditional IRA
Compare when paying tax now may beat a deduction today and when the opposite can be true.
Roth versus Traditional is usually a tax-rate question first and an account-type question second.
Use this guide to understand the tradeoffs quickly, then open one of the related models below if you want to turn the idea into a planning scenario.
The core tradeoff
Roth contributions are taxed now and can be withdrawn tax free later if the rules are met. Traditional contributions may reduce taxes now but are typically taxed later on withdrawal.
That means the better choice often depends on whether your future tax rate is likely to be higher or lower than your current one.
Why diversification helps
Many households do not need a winner-take-all answer. Holding both Roth and pretax assets can create flexibility later.
That flexibility matters when you are managing brackets, Medicare premiums, or required withdrawals.
Conclusion
The best answer is often a blend. Use the comparison calculator to see how the tradeoff changes under different tax assumptions.
Related models
View all modelsRelated guides
View all6 min
How Roth conversions work
Learn when Roth conversions may make sense and what tradeoffs to model.
Read insight5 min
RMD basics
A simple introduction to required minimum distributions and why they matter.
Read insight